Part Writing Rules: 5 Four-Part Harmony Mistakes That Cost the Most Points
Part-writing assignments are graded chord by chord, and the same few errors keep showing up in red ink. Whether you're in AP Music Theory, preparing for ABRSM or studying harmony at a conservatory, this guide is for checking your own work.
How do you read the examples?
Every example is in C major and lists four notes from the bottom up: bass, tenor, alto, soprano. C4 is middle C, so C3 G3 C4 E4 means bass C3, tenor G3, alto C4 and soprano E4. The text in quotation marks is exactly what Michord's Harmony Mode shows on screen with the interface set to English.
The College Board's AP Music Theory course outline lists four-part SATB voice leading, with doubling, voicing and spacing, under Unit 4.
1. Why do parallel fifths and octaves cost points?
Two voices moving from one perfect fifth or octave to another stop sounding independent: four voices become three. The voice leading rules guide covers the why in depth; here's what it looks like in an assignment.
| I → ii (bass, tenor, alto, soprano) | Harmony Mode shows | |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong | C3 G3 C4 E4 → D3 A3 D4 F4 | "Parallel 5ths" (bass–tenor), "Parallel 8ves" (bass–alto) |
| Right | C3 G3 E4 C5 → D3 F3 D4 A4 | No flag |
In the wrong version every voice climbs a step with the bass. The fix lets the bass rise while the upper voices step down; contrary motion against the bass prevents most parallels.
The classic trap is IV → V, where the roots sit a step apart. F3 A3 C4 F4 → G3 B3 D4 G4 gets "Parallel 5ths" (bass–alto) and "Parallel 8ves" (bass–soprano), even though the cadence label correctly reads "Half cadence — resting on the dominant". Rewrite it as F3 C4 F4 A4 → G3 B3 D4 G4: bass up, upper voices down.
What about contrary octaves, where two voices move in opposite directions from one octave to another? Many strict-style textbooks mark them too. They aren't among the examples tested for this post, so check them by hand against your own book.
2. What are hidden (direct) fifths and octaves?
A hidden fifth or hidden octave, also called a direct fifth or direct octave, happens when the outer voices move in the same direction into a perfect fifth or octave from some other interval. The Voice leading article on Wikipedia defines hidden consecutives as perfect intervals reached by two voices moving the same way, especially when the higher voice leaps.
| I → V (bass, tenor, alto, soprano) | Harmony Mode shows | |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong | C3 G3 C4 E4 → G3 B3 D4 G4 | "Hidden 8ves" |
| Right | C3 G3 C4 E4 → G2 G3 B3 D4 | No flag |
Bass and soprano both rise and land on G, an octave apart. Send the bass down to G2 instead: the outer voices no longer arrive on an octave, and the soprano moves only by step (E to D), so Harmony Mode shows no warning. The outer voices do still arrive on a perfect fifth (G2–D4) in similar motion, but most textbooks allow it because the soprano moves by step. A leap into a fifth is different: C3 G3 C4 E4 → F3 A3 C4 C5 gets "Hidden 5ths", because the bass rises to F while the soprano leaps up to C.
What is a direct fifth?
It's simply another name for a hidden fifth. Many textbooks allow one when the soprano moves by step and object only when the soprano leaps, so look up the exact rule in the book your school uses.
3. What is the difference between voice overlap and voice crossing?
Voice overlap happens between two chords: a voice moves past the note its neighbor held in the previous chord. Say the tenor rises above the alto's last note: the lines blur, though nothing actually crosses. Harmony Mode marks this with "Overlap".
Voice crossing happens inside a single chord: the alto sounds above the soprano, or the tenor below the bass. Michord doesn't show crossing separately. It assigns voices by pitch, lowest note to bass and highest to soprano, so a crossed alto simply reads as the soprano. Check crossing on paper.
Fix: when a voice moves far, make sure it doesn't pass its neighbor's previous note; swapping chord tones between voices often solves it.
4. Why must the leading tone resolve?
The leading tone, B in C major, sits a half step below the tonic and wants to rise to it. The Rules of Melody section in Music Theory for the 21st-Century Classroom (University of Puget Sound) lists scale degree 7 going to 8 among the tendency tones that should resolve.
| V → I (bass, tenor, alto, soprano) | Harmony Mode shows | |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong | G2 D4 G4 B4 → C3 C4 E4 G4 | "Leading tone"; "Imperfect authentic cadence" |
| Right | G2 D4 G4 B4 → C3 E4 G4 C5 | No flag; "Perfect authentic cadence" |
In the wrong version the soprano B drops to G. Let it rise to C and you get a perfect authentic cadence: root-position chords, tonic in the soprano. For how dominant and tonic work together, see the functional harmony guide.
5. Why must the seventh resolve down?
In G7, the seventh is F. It is a dissonance, and in four-part harmony it resolves down by step, F to E. Moving it up is the fifth mistake.
| V7 → I (bass, tenor, alto, soprano) | Harmony Mode shows | |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong | G2 B3 D4 F4 → C3 C4 E4 G4 | "7th" |
| Right | G2 F3 B3 G4 → C3 E3 C4 G4 | No flag; chord shown as "G7(no5)" |
In the wrong version the soprano F climbs to G. The fix uses an incomplete V7, with no fifth and the root doubled, so the seventh F can fall to E while the leading tone B rises to C, producing a complete tonic triad. More on chord sevenths in the seventh chords guide.
What do you have to check by hand?
Doubling and spacing live inside a single chord, not between two, and Michord checks neither. Mark them on paper:
- Doubling. In root-position triads, double the root (the bass note); the Puget Sound summary of doubling rules also covers first and second inversion. Never double the leading tone, and don't double the seventh of V7.
- Spacing. Keep soprano–alto and alto–tenor within an octave; tenor–bass can be wider. This is exactly the rule in the Rules of Spacing section of the same textbook.
- Range. Keep each voice inside the ranges your textbook gives. Books differ slightly; the Puget Sound text bases its voice ranges on Bach's chorales.
What does Michord check, and what doesn't it?
Michord is a desktop music theory app for macOS 11+ (Apple Silicon) and Windows 10+. You play on a MIDI keyboard, the on-screen piano or your computer keyboard. Harmony Mode checks the connection between each pair of consecutive chords and shows your last eight chords side by side. Its seven rule-based checks: two errors, "Parallel 5ths" and "Parallel 8ves", and five warnings, "Hidden 5ths", "Hidden 8ves", "Overlap", "Leading tone" and "7th".
Its limits:
- Voices are assigned by pitch. The lowest note you play is the bass and the highest is the soprano, which is why crossing isn't shown.
- Different note counts are skipped.
G3 B3 D4 → C3 G3 C4 E4(three notes to four) is not checked. - The leading-tone check covers the outer voices (bass and soprano) and V → I only.
- Doubling, spacing and range are not checked.
- No inversion figures. C with E in the bass shows as
C/E, Roman numeralI. Figured bass is covered in the chord inversions guide.
It doesn't read paper or listen to recordings, and it doesn't replace your teacher; it gives instant feedback while you play.
| Feature | Free | PRO |
|---|---|---|
| MIDI keyboard input, real grand piano sound, note names on the piano | Yes | Yes |
| Chord symbols and Roman numerals | — | Yes |
| Cadence names | — | Yes |
| Harmony Mode (7 checks) | — | Yes |
How to check a part-writing assignment in 4 steps
- Play the chords one at a time, with exactly the voicing you wrote.
- Read the flag at every connection and find the notes on your paper.
- Mark doubling and spacing by hand, chord by chord, plus range.
- Check the cadence. Does the label you see match the one the exercise asks for?
Fix it on paper, then play it again. Preparing for an entrance exam? The music school audition preparation guide has a weekly plan.
Conclusion
Learn to spot the five connection mistakes, then check doubling, spacing and range yourself. Download Michord for macOS or Windows. The permanent Free plan needs no credit card. Harmony Mode, chord symbols, Roman numerals and cadence names come with PRO: 2.99 USD per month or 22.99 USD per year.
Play your exercise and see parallels, hidden octaves and unresolved tendency tones flagged at every connection. Free plan, no credit card; Harmony Mode comes with PRO (2.99 USD/month · 22.99 USD/year).
Download MichordFrequently Asked Questions
What are the basic part writing rules in four-part harmony?
Avoid parallel and hidden (direct) fifths and octaves, avoid overlap and crossing, resolve the leading tone up and the seventh down by step. Then check doubling, spacing and range.
What is a direct fifth?
A direct fifth, also called a hidden fifth, happens when two voices, usually the bass and soprano, move in the same direction into a perfect fifth from some other interval. Many textbooks accept it when the soprano moves by step and object when the soprano leaps.
What is the difference between voice crossing and voice overlap?
Crossing happens inside one chord: a lower voice sounds above a higher one, such as the alto above the soprano. Overlap happens between two chords: a voice moves past the note its neighbor just had in the previous chord, without actually crossing it.
Can Michord check my whole part-writing assignment?
No. Harmony Mode checks each connection between two chords you play. It does not check doubling, spacing or range, and it does not replace your teacher.
Is Harmony Mode free?
No. Harmony Mode, chord symbols, Roman numerals and cadence names are part of PRO: 2.99 USD per month or 22.99 USD per year. The permanent Free plan needs no credit card and includes MIDI keyboard input, a real grand piano sound and note names on the piano.